I really liked this book. I admit I was a little shocked since it is YA, but I enjoyed Sarah MacLean's adult historicals so I thought I'd give this a try. The romance was cute and sweet but I really liked the mystery as well. The characters acted appropriately for their age and the secondary characters were well rounded and interesting. It's been quite a few years (to say the least!) since I've been this age but I was still able to identify with their feelings and actions. I would recommend this to anyone who enjoyed Sarah's other books.